All News  March 1, 2017, 7:51 pm  |  @Lifeographies

A formal response from the World Press Photo Foundation.


referred to the news: http://www.lifeographies.com/news/28/

 Let me cut to the conclusion?—?this article repeats allegations that have already been independently investigated. When the evidence from that investigation was presented to a post-award jury, that jury concluded it did not conclusively substantiate the allegations so there was insufficient evidence declare a clear breach of our contest entry rules.

For those coming to this story for the first time, let me explain the process that led to that conclusion.

Following receipt of an email on 14 February 2017 from Ramin Talaie alleging one of the Long-Term Project winners, Hossein Fatemi, was engaged in unethical practices, we began investigating the relevant issues raised in the document attached to the email. This article is a facsimile of that document. It was what prompted our actions. So it marks the beginning rather than the end of this issue.

The investigation concerned those photographs discussed above that were also in Hossein’s story as submitted to our contest. They are the only photographs that could be our focus. The process we followed was in accordance with our judging procedures, which are transparent on our website. In particular, we followed the procedure for handling issues that arise after an award has been made, as detailed on page 30 of the Judging Procedures handbook, which is available online for all to see.

On 15 February we commissioned Santiago Lyon to conduct an independent investigation into these allegations. Santiago is a greatly respected figure in photojournalism, with some thirty years experience in the field, and a comprehensive commitment to ethics. We asked him to gather as much evidence as he could, principally by interviewing people living in Iran and elsewhere, who were present when the photos in Hossein’s winning story that were identified by you as having issues, were taken. Santiago conducted hours of interviews, in addition to speaking at length with Hossein and Ramin.

It is important to note that Ramin was not present when any of the photos he criticises in the winning story were taken, so he does not have direct experience of the circumstances he discusses. In contrast, the investigation included interviews with people who were actually there when the disputed photos in the contest entry were taken.

Santiago presented summaries of his interviews and other information to the post-award jury for consideration. The post-award jury then deliberated for some time on the accusations in light of the evidence that presented.

This was a difficult case to investigate and decide upon and we could only judge the images that were part of the contest. We have been very precise in following the established procedures, Santiago’s investigation was thorough, and the post-award jury treated both the allegations and the evidence provided to them with equal seriousness.

There is often a lot of social media commentary on issues like this, and we see it already in response to this article. Too often that discussion involves personal issues and disputes and takes place without good evidence from independent sources. By commissioning an independent investigation to inform our post-award jury we have done everything we can to establish what evidence exists relating to the photographs in Hossein’s story, and that alone was the basis for the jury’s conclusion.

If in future additional, compelling evidence comes to light then this should be shared directly with us and it will be rigorously examined too. But this article is just a repeat of the already investigated allegations, so does not give us anything new to consider.

It is just not possible to easily judge a case that has so much of a ‘he said versus she said’ quality about it. This is also basically the response we have had from publications that published the work and conducted their own scrutiny of Hossein’s work. They all came up with a similar result. All I can say is that we did our utmost best to find answers to questions. Based on the answers we could find it was judged. Those are the facts.


referred to the news: http://www.lifeographies.com/news/28/

All News »

» A formal response from the World Press Photo Foundation.   March 1, 2017, 7:51 pm
Let me cut to the conclusion?—?this article repeats allegations that have already been independently investigated. ...More

» 2017 World Press Photo Awards Fake News   March 1, 2017, 5:06 pm
This year the jury of the World Press Photo (WPP) awarded Iranian photographer, Hossein Fatemi, the second place for his long-term project titled 'An Iranian Journey.’ ...More

» Known Image Restrictions   January 16, 2017, 11:53 am
Please consult the listing below for currently known intellectual property infringement issues. If you have any questions concerning these issues, please email support@lifeographies.com. Thank you! ...More

» Capturing the World’s Largest Ambrotypes with Actor Gary Oldman   January 11, 2017, 10:22 pm
Capturing beautiful stories. That’s what wet plate photographer Ian Ruhter set out to do for his 3-year project at Slab City. ...More

» Panasonic Finally Unveils the GH5 with 4K/60p Video and 5-Axis Stabilization   January 4, 2017, 9:42 pm
We’re not expecting a lot of exciting camera announcements from CES this year, but the Panasonic GH5 is a big fat exception.  ...More

» Model Releases and other documents   January 4, 2017, 2:50 pm
All images containing recognizable people require a model release. There are no exceptions. Look at the image and ask yourself “Could any of these people depicted recognize themselves in this picture?“ ...More

» Free Online Keywording Tool, IPTC editor, suggestions for photo tags   January 4, 2017, 1:42 pm
This tool will suggest keywords based on similar images, and it lets you compare keyword popularity. The site aims to serve the needs of photographers and illustrators in their quest to tag/keyword their images.  ...More

» German Photographer Sued Facebook for Removing EXIF Data, and He Won   November 23, 2016, 10:29 pm
If you’re keeping track today, the score is Big Corporations: 1, Photographers: 1. Because while Carol Highsmith might have all-but-lost her epic lawsuit against Getty Images, a photographer in Germany came out on top when he took Facebook to court. ...More

» Microsoft’s New Surface Studio PC is a Creative Dream, Wants to Kill the iMac   October 26, 2016, 9:06 pm
The iMac with its beautiful 27-inch high-res screen and minimal design has long been a favorite of many creatives—if not for their studio, then as their home computer.  ...More

» Sony Announces New Flagship a6500 Mirrorless Camera   October 14, 2016, 12:44 pm
Sony continues to churn out quality mirrorless cameras with the latest installment of their flagship APS-C camera. The a6500, an update to the acclaimed a6300 released last February, ...More

» This is how you take a soft light group shot   July 5, 2016, 11:10 am
I am a long time follower of Clay Cook, and one thing that always amazes me is his softly lit group shots. I mean soft light for one person is easy,  ...More

» Brutal Truth: Nobody Cares About Your Photography   June 29, 2016, 12:31 am
>Ted Forbes of The Art of Photography made this 7.5-minute video in which he talks about a brutal truth of photography: the fact that  ...More

» Hoka Hey: A Documentary About War Photographer Jason P. Howe   May 31, 2016, 3:26 pm
Jason P. Howe is a self-taught photographer who started documenting the conflict in Colombia starting in 2001.  ...More

» Steve McCurry: I’m a Visual Storyteller Not a Photojournalist   May 30, 2016, 8:54 pm
Steve McCurry will rein in his use of Photoshop after he was accused of manipulating some of his images, the famed photographer exclusively tells TIME. ...More

» Four Sherpas Just Climbed Everest with 360° Camera Rigs on Their Backs   May 30, 2016, 12:39 am
Congratulations are in order for all of us couch potatoes: thanks to four incredible, dedicated sherpas, we can now 'climb' to the top of the tallest mountain on Earth from the comfort of the nearest recliner. ...More

» The Photographer Who Captures Tiny Post-Apocalyptic Worlds   May 29, 2016, 10:49 pm
The Drawing Room created this 8-minute mini-documentary about the work of photographer Lori Nix and Kathleen Gerber, a duo now known as Nix+Gerber. ...More

» Content Aware Crop is Coming   May 29, 2016, 10:17 pm
Adobe announced today that the next Photoshop CC update will contain a brand new feature called Content-Aware Crop.  ...More

» IMPORTANT CHANGES   May 25, 2016, 10:31 pm
Old content of www.lifeographies.com web site was moved to the new domain www.pavalache.com  ...More

» Leica M (Typ 262) is a Return to the Basics of Digital M Rangefinder Photography   November 22, 2015, 11:56 pm
Leica today unveiled the new Leica M (Typ 262), the fourth model in the Leica M lineup alongside the Leica M (Typ 240), Leica M-P (Typ 240) ...More

» A brief guide to standards, Photoshop and captions   November 19, 2015, 7:20 pm
Everything we do as Reuters journalists has to be independent, free from bias and executed with the utmost integrity. ...More

» Reuters Issues a Worldwide Ban on RAW Photos   November 18, 2015, 11:12 pm
Reuters has implemented a new worldwide policy for freelance photographers that bans photos that were processed from RAW files.  ...More

» Affinity Photo is a New Pro Photoshop Alternative for Mac Users: Get It for Free   February 9, 2015, 9:36 pm
Affinity Photo is a new program that was launched today by the England-based software company Serif.  ...More

» Microstock Expo is Back!   February 9, 2015, 8:57 pm
Microstock Expo is back, bigger and better than ever! The big news is that Bruce Livingstone will keynote. We’re super chuffed to have the Godfather of microstock opening the conference! ...More

» A Simple Video Tutorial on Creating a Hyperlapse with Your DSLR   January 27, 2015, 1:17 am
If you’ve been itching to try your hand at shooting a hyperlapse video, the short and sweet video tutorial above may be a nice place to start your journey. ...More

» Disabled Photographer Petitioning Canon to Make a DSLR for Left-Handed People   January 25, 2015, 1:36 am
Throughout the history of photography, cameras have mostly been designed with right handed people in mind. ...More

» Adobe Lightroom 6 Will Only Be Compatible with 64-Bit Operating Systems   January 23, 2015, 1:43 pm
If you want to stay up to date with Adobe’s Lightroom software, you’ll need to make sure you’re up to date with the latest operating systems. ...More

» Space Awaits! Shooting a Photo of Young Astronauts in Their Backyard Space Program   January 23, 2015, 1:30 pm
Space Awaits! is a personal project I did. I came up with the idea of a photo shoot featuring young astronauts. ...More